Consider the following argument and its map. “What’s your o…
Consider the following argument and its map. “What’s your opinion of science? Do you, like those people mentioned above, place a high value on scientific research? Despite the unquestionable appeal of science, a bit of reflection shows that 1 we should terminate all scientific research. After all, 2 terminating all scientific research would make the world a safer place because 3 terminating all scientific research would prevent the development of new weapons and because 4 if we prevent the development of new weapons then the world will be safer. Obviously, 5 we have an obligation to create a safer world for our descendants, so 6 we should do whatever it takes to make the world a safer place.” MC 3.4a Central Argument.pngSuppose Allen thinks that premises 3, 4 and 5 are all good and that inferences A, B, and C are all very strong. Should he conclude that the argument, as a whole, is good?
Read DetailsConsider the following argument and its map. “What’s your o…
Consider the following argument and its map. “What’s your opinion of science? Do you, like those people mentioned above, place a high value on scientific research? Despite the unquestionable appeal of science, a bit of reflection shows that 1 we should terminate all scientific research. After all, 2 terminating all scientific research would make the world a safer place because 3 terminating all scientific research would prevent the development of new weapons and because 4 if we prevent the development of new weapons then the world will be safer. Obviously, 5 we have an obligation to create a safer world for our descendants, so 6 we should do whatever it takes to make the world a safer place.” MC 3.4a Central Argument.pngTrue or false? If we examine this missing premise and decide that it is false, this shows that inference B is bad.
Read DetailsConsider the following argument and its map. “What’s your o…
Consider the following argument and its map. “What’s your opinion of science? Do you, like those people mentioned above, place a high value on scientific research? Despite the unquestionable appeal of science, a bit of reflection shows that 1 we should terminate all scientific research. After all, 2 terminating all scientific research would make the world a safer place because 3 terminating all scientific research would prevent the development of new weapons and because 4 if we prevent the development of new weapons then the world will be safer. Obviously, 5 we have an obligation to create a safer world for our descendants, so 6 we should do whatever it takes to make the world a safer place.” MC 3.4a Central Argument.pngSuppose Ellen doesn’t think that terminating all scientific research would make the world a safer place. What should she do?
Read Details