Both Thoreau and Dreher believe that if you want to have pri…
Both Thoreau and Dreher believe that if you want to have private virtue, you must retreat in some sense from mainstream culture. What does Thoreau think we need to retreat from and why? What does Dreher think we need to retreat from and why?
Read DetailsAnimal Farm presents an economic revolution and demonstrates…
Animal Farm presents an economic revolution and demonstrates some of the logistical difficulties in having a successful (i.e. viable and lasting) economic revolution. Name and explain three of these problems / logistical difficulties.
Read DetailsAquinas’ argument that private property is right (because it…
Aquinas’ argument that private property is right (because it is beneficial for the common good) but not a right depends upon the Christian principle of the common good. The reality of the problem of the Tragedy of the Commons demonstrates that the idea of the common good will not prevent people from acting in ways that support their own interests by destroying the common good. Does the “common good” have any practical force in business and/or economic decisions or are all these decisions motivated purely by private interests? In your answer be sure to explain how Aquinas uses the “common good” in his thought about private property and how the “common good” functions in the tragedy of the commons. Also be sure to give a specific example to illustrate your answer on the practical force of the idea of the common good.
Read DetailsAquinas’ definition of charity as giving out of one’s superf…
Aquinas’ definition of charity as giving out of one’s superfluity makes charity a matter of prudence rather than virtue. In modern society, the loss of stable stations of living, with the corresponding loss of superfluity, has made charity a non-prudential but virtuous action. Which model is better for society, taking into account both economics and virtue, and why? Be sure to demonstrate a knowledge of Aquinas’ and Hirschfeld’s arguments that include details from the texts not in our course notes.
Read Details